Pew Adjacent
The Bible has murder, betrayal, bad marriages, and a talking donkey. Nobody ever told Verity any of it.
She grew up pew adjacent. Close enough to see it, never actually in it. Now she’s asking her brother Dakota everything she’s wondered. He was a preacher for 15 years. We’re reading the Bible in order, one weird, wild, surprisingly relatable story at a time.
New episodes every week. No sermons, no church background needed.
Pew Adjacent
Cain and Abel Explained: Where Did Cain’s Wife Come From?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Verity thought the Bible had about four people in it. Then Cain gets a wife a few verses later, and she wants to know where that wife came from. In this episode of Pew Adjacent, she reads Genesis 4 for the first time and takes her questions about Cain and Abel and the first murder in the Bible to her brother Dakota, who was a preacher for over 15 years. They get into why God turned down Cain’s offering, what it means that Abel’s blood cries out from the ground, and why she keeps skipping the genealogies. There’s also a guy named Matt in a basement. Next week is Noah.
Follow Pew Adjacent on Instagram and Facebook @pewadjacent.
New episodes every week. If you like the show, a rating or review helps more people find it.
Questions for Dakota? pewadjacentpod@gmail.com
Intro
VerityI always thought there was Adam and Eve, and there was Cain and Abel, and that was it. I thought the cast of the Bible is pretty small. Then one of the boys kills the other and the survivor says he's scared somebody's gonna kill him. But who's gonna kill him? Because now there's three people. In my mind, there's three people now.
DakotaYeah.
VerityAnd then a few verses later, he gets a wife. Well, where did she come from?
DakotaWelcome back, party people. Pew Adjacent Episode four. Verity continues to read the scriptures and continues to have questions that would make a grandma blush. Not our grandma, she wouldn't blush. No, she's crazy. She'd ask these questions.
VerityI love to visit her when other people are with us because she asks some crazy questions.
DakotaYeah. Plus, she's got the age thing working for her, so there's no more filter.
VerityYeah.
DakotaIf there ever was one, I don't know.
VerityBut no, I don't think there was one, but I think she does use it to her advantage.
DakotaYeah, it's a pretty good time. Sometimes it gets a little weird, but it's all entertaining.
VerityYeah.
DakotaWhere are we moving on to now?
Cain & Abel: The Setup
VerityWe're still in Genesis, which I gotta say was a good first book to start in because there's a lot of stuff happening. So we got through Adam and Eve, we did creation, we have the Garden of Eden, we have Adam and Eve. Now they've been evicted. So they're on the move, right? And now we're on to Cain and Abel, which even me who doesn't know anything about the Bible had heard of Cain and Abel and was somewhat aware that there was a murder. So I kind of knew that. And that's it. So that's where we're at today. I always thought there was Adam and Eve, and there was Cain and Abel, and that was it. I thought the cast of the Bible is pretty small. Then one of the boys kills the other, and the survivor says he's scared somebody's gonna kill him. But who's gonna kill him? Because now there's three people. In my mind, there's three people now.
DakotaYeah.
Cain's Wife & Population
VerityAnd then a few verses later, he gets a wife. Well, where did she come from? So that was a question that kept coming up. So I want to start there, and then maybe we'll backtrack to Cain and Abel and why the murder happened.
DakotaSure. Okay. So populating the earth, right?
VerityYes.
DakotaSo procreation begins with Adam and Eve. They are not born of woman. So again, no belly buttons, probably. But then they are told to be fruitful and multiply. So they do, and they have children. But we're not given an exhaustive list of the children that they had or when they had them, right? Because we do learn that they're living to like 900 years old. So their aging is slower. They're having kids probably over the course of those centuries. I guess you'd mark their time by.
VerityYou're saying we didn't get an exhaustive list of the kids that Adam and Eve had? You would think our two main players, the two OGs, that we would get the full list.
DakotaAaron Powell Well, yeah, we assume those are the first ones. Right? But you think they just stopped there, you know? Well, we know they have another one that's mentioned here in a minute, but we don't know the gaps and all that. We don't know. I mean, there's a lot of stuff that we're gonna have to interject as far as the practicalities of how this all worked. I just think it wouldn't be right to assume all Adam and Eve are dealing with is Cain and Abel as their children, you know. They're told to multiply to fill the earth. And I mean, think of things like there is no birth control. They don't understand probably any of that. They just know what they're supposed to do to procreate the earth. And so they begin to do that. You're introduced first to Cain and Abel and what happens there to highlight, again, piggybacking off of what just happened with Adam and Eve, and now what that means for creation, right? So because of what they did, they introduced sin into the world, but that also means they introduced death into our human bodies, and that doesn't happen right away. It's a decay over time because of sin, but it's an indication that sin is in there now. So Cain and Abel's story is used to highlight here's a direct result of what Adam and Eve did and how it's going to affect the world. So not only are we dying from within and without, but we're also bringing death from within our hateful hearts out towards others. So you're affected by sin outwardly and inwardly, and this is the first prime example of that in the world. So as far as population goes, I'm assuming that there were lots of kids over a large numbers of years, and yeah, I think you have to safely assume that occurred within the family some multiplication.
VerityOkay. Yeah. That's on my list of questions, too. I didn't really consider that maybe they just left out some of the children, but so they did. You have 900 years of life, you're gonna probably produce quite a litter. So if they have kids with each other, they're all siblings, and they have kids with each other, did those kids turn out okay?
DakotaWell, yeah. Again, assuming, especially the fact that they're living so long, assuming they turned out okay because the world continued to be populated, and I guess we're okay still. I don't know. But the negative effects on our bodies wouldn't have just like happened overnight. There's a I'm not gonna use that phrase again, slow burn, but there's a slow there's a slow decay of and a slow infiltration of what sin is biologically doing to our bodies and everything. So apparently I say apparently, because I wasn't there, I'm not sure on this, but what we know now and what the Bible calls out eventually, the incestuous relationships that would have happened, I assume weren't able to cause what they caused now, if you know what I mean. Because very quickly the earth became well populated. Okay, so then you're talking about cousins. And then you're talking about second cousins, third cousins, fourth cousins, fifth cousins, sixth cousin. I mean, it's going down the line pretty rapidly after that. So I guess you could always say you can trace our lineage, which we'll get to Noah, but you can trace our lineage all the way back to one ancestor if you believe the Bible.
VerityYeah.
DakotaRight? So that's how it goes.
VerityOkay. So maybe God gave the first ones like a pass. Whereas today you didn't get a pass because he's like, We gotta get this place filled up. So Yeah.
DakotaAnd I look at it like this like the waters get diluted pretty quick. So yeah, you gotta get past those first generations, but after that, it gets diluted pretty fast.
VerityOkay. I'm just gonna have to let that one go.
DakotaYeah. I don't know. I don't know what else to think about it.
VeritySo Cain and Abel,
The Offering & the Heart
Veritywere they twins or was one older than the other?
DakotaYeah. It says the man knew his wife Eve, she conceived and gave birth to Cain. She said, I've gotten a man with the help of Yahweh. And again, she gave birth to his brother Abel.
VeritySo um So Cain was first and then Abel.
DakotaYeah.
VerityAnd the problem was that Cain and Abel presented an offering to God, and Abel's offering was accepted, and Cain's wasn't. But it doesn't say why it wasn't. So what did he do wrong?
DakotaWe find evidence for that in the outcome of Yahweh communicating that he kind of rejected Cain's offering and accepted Abel's. Because he gives instruction to Cain, like, hey, if you do well, won't this be fine? Won't everything be okay with you? Uh what does he say? If you do not do well, sin is lying at the door and it desires you, but you must rule over it. So, in other words, you can get upset about this and let your heart do what it wants to do, or you can overcome that and gain the right heart for this. But obviously, immediately what happens is he gets mad about that and he kills Abel. Abel offers the first of his flock, so he offers a living animal. Cain offers the first of his fruit of the field. But Abel is communicating what's in his heart through that is a deeper devotion to Yahweh. He's giving the most valuable thing, and he's doing so from a heart, apparently, that is more devoted to Yahweh. What is revealed by this murderous spirit that Cain has towards Abel is that his heart wasn't towards Yahweh. He was just wanting to appease and he didn't love. I guess that's a good way to say it. And that's one thing that you learn throughout the whole Bible, starting now, is that God may have commands for you to do certain things, but he's looking for the heart behind it.
VerityUh-huh.
DakotaHe doesn't need these offerings. There's nothing from us that he needs, but he wants a heart toward him, and Cain doesn't have it. Um Abel does. Okay.
VerityThat's like when my husband gives me a gift, if it's out of obligation versus wanting to give me a gift, it's different.
DakotaPerfect.
VerityLike Valentine's Day. These guys rushing all around getting flowers and cards and chocolates and stuff out of obligation. Like get out of here. I don't want it.
DakotaYeah. Exactly. Like that. Okay. Yep. I don't remember reading that in there.
VerityBut okay. So Cain then gets ticked and kills Abel.
DakotaUh-huh.
VerityAnd
God Confronts Cain
Veritythen God comes around. And another one of those rhetorical questions that we talked about, like when you ask your kid, what did you do? But you know what they did. And he's like, Where's Abel? What did you do?
DakotaYeah, he freaking killed him, man. How terrible. Yeah. He killed his brother.
VerityAnd it says, What? Tell your brother?
DakotaWell, we still joke. I mean, we you know, joke about in a house full of boys, like, you know, if we're leaving or something like, don't kill your brother, you know, or whatever.
VerityYeah.
DakotaBut the fact that he would actually want to do that, desire to do that.
VerityYeah. And then what was it God said, like the his blood is in the ground?
DakotaIt cries out to me from the ground, yeah.
VerityYeah. So that was different to read about.
DakotaIt's interesting to hear your viewpoint on this because I'm just so used to when I read the Bible, I don't have a literal lens on a lot of things. And so I'm just kind of moving past that. But it's a really important thing to look at and question to ask. Like, what is that? What does that mean? Because blood's crying out to me from the ground. I just read that as what do you call it? The wrong done to Abel God feels, God knows, God sees, because he's aware of that.
VerityYeah.
DakotaSo I just, I don't know, I don't want to like over-spiritualize, but that's just kind of how I would read that. But actually, what are we talking about here?
VeritySo Well, yeah, like his blood was probably literally on the ground, right?
DakotaYeah, there's a literal sense to this. Maybe it's that since he does see all things, the earth can't hide anything from the Lord. So he can see blood was spilt, I guess. He takes account of that.
VerityYeah, like he can sense it. Even if it wasn't like literally red, he can sense it.
DakotaLike harm was done. Well, and j Jesus takes it a step further in the New Testament and he says, if you have hate for your brother in your heart, then you're guilty of murder.
VerityLike overall hate or like hate on a daily basis.
DakotaLike probably like deep-seated hate. Deep seated.
VerityThat's different than if he like steals your toy and sells it back to you. Sure.
DakotaYeah. Well, that happened. Yeah.
VerityJust to you, right?
DakotaUh huh. Yeah, I hope so. Yeah.
VerityYeah, I've asked that anywhere else.
DakotaBut he didn't desire to kill me when he sold me back my own toy.
VerityNo, he's happy. Yeah. Yeah.
DakotaAnd that was just his brilliant way of making money off me.
VerityYeah. That was funny.
DakotaEven when my boys, you know, there's lots of fights here. And I don't think they've ever wanted to physically kill each other.
VerityNo.
DakotaI mean, they can get to a degree of anger that's really extreme, but it's never let's end your life right now. You know?
VerityYeah. Yeah.
DakotaI had boys. She had boys.
VerityI get irritated. We just send them downstairs to work it out. Work it out on the mat. Yeah. That's what I did.
DakotaTake it to the mat.
VerityAnd then they just resolved it.
DakotaI'm picturing a really funny SNL skit right now where you guys are like, just take it to the mat. And then there's just a guy in your basement named Matt, and he just sits there and he's just always down there and he acts like their counselor. You know? Because you're envisioning as they're going down, they're going to wrestle and all this sort of stuff. There's just a guy in a folding chair named Matt. Hey, what's up? I'm down here in the space. Yeah.
VerityI didn't think you were going to go that direction with it, but kids need as a skit, for sure.
DakotaYeah. This episode is brought to you by Wild Root Essentials. Anybody who is anybody today, anybody with a pulse understands that stress is a part of life, and maybe increasingly more so as the days go by. Whether you go looking for it or not, it finds you. Well, Wild Root Essentials has got a whole stress relief line built exactly for that. Simple, natural stuff to help you actually exhale at the end of the day and feel good about it. There are different ways to de-stress, but Wild Root Essentials is going to make sure that you do so in a way that benefits your body and your well-being. Check out the full collection at Wildroot Essentials.com. All right, let's get back into it.
VeritySo Abel's out. He's gone. There was probably other siblings, but the Bible says that Adam and Eve have another son named Seth. Seth was a really popular name when I was a kid, but I don't hear it much anymore.
DakotaWell, I think it has come back. Really? There's people probably a generation the generation below me, which I have no idea what that is, but there's a lot of Seth's in that generation. Yeah.
VerityI like it.
DakotaWe have a cousin, I think, whose middle name is Seth.
VerityOh, really?
DakotaYeah.
VerityOkay. Yeah, I like it.
Seth & the Genealogies
VerityBut Seth then just jumps right over. Seth has a son, but I'm like, wait a minute, who's the wife of Seth? Who's the mother of this son? Where did she come from? So I guess this is going back to the there was other kids that Adam and Eve had.
DakotaWell, Cain and Abel probably had kids.
VerityDid Abel have kids?
DakotaProbably. I'm assuming. I mean, that story is so short. You can assume safely, and you don't have to have certainty that he pro I mean, he was a grown man. He had a job, a career.
VerityOh. Okay. Yeah, I didn't get a sense of like how old they were. And I gotta say that there are parts in this book where it's like whole paragraphs or whole sections that it just lists a bunch of names. It's a bunch of lineage. And I gotta say I skip over it because I can't pronounce most of those words anyway. Is it okay to skip over that?
DakotaYeah, I think they are interesting to go back towards. They're genealogical records, is what they are, but some of them are interesting to go back through and see if you can pull out names that maybe you see somewhere else. And I think the most interesting genealogy is Jesus genealogy. The names that are included in that are really interesting. And then you find out that you well, you ask the question, why are these names they're part of his genealogy, but why is it not every name included? Why are some of these names included, or why are some of these women's names included even? And then you begin to find out why. And so it's like that with this too, but as you're just reading through, I would just kinda go through it and okay, keep that for later.
VerityYeah, skip over that. But it's a lot of men.
DakotaYeah, we're going through your father's name.
VerityYeah, the the women are like skipped over, which is rude.
DakotaWell, not always. The most important genealogy in the Bible, there's four women, and that's not normal.
VerityOh.
DakotaSo yeah.
VerityOkay. Well, I've been skipping over those parts, but Cain and Abel, it was a short story, and I thought we missed a lot of details, but I also thought that it was worth having a discussion about as an entire episode because it was one I've heard of and I knew that there was like brothers and murder. So it was interesting to me.
DakotaWell, and think about when you read the Bible, think about how it's structured. That's a big part of this. Because we wouldn't have been able to read all the books if they recorded every single thing or person in human history. So why is that specific short story of Cain and Abel included directly after Genesis 3? Because it reveals how sin then affected the world. Now, were there other instances of sin before that? Of course. You have Adam and Eve, and then all the stuff that they do after they leave the garden and stuff their kids do after they have them. And so this story is there for a purpose to highlight it actually means for sin to come into the world.
The First Murder
VerityBut this was the first murder.
DakotaYeah. Probably. Yeah, probably never happened before.
VerityYeah. Was Eve like, you killed my son, and kick him out of the house?
DakotaI don't know. Probably didn't live with him. Maybe they did. I don't know. See, that stuff we don't know. We have to kind of Yeah, we just kind of have to guess. I don't know. But I'm sure there was quite the drama, yeah.
VerityYeah.
DakotaWell, think about if you've never seen that before or heard of that.
VerityWell, yeah. How did he even know to do it?
DakotaI don't know. Just the evil intent of his heart drove him to the most extreme thing he could think of. And think how horrific that would be for Adam and Eve or whoever else was around if they had never seen that before.
VerityYeah, I didn't think about that.
DakotaIt might even be the first death, a human death.
VerityOh yeah. I'll bet it is.
DakotaI mean, that's a shock to everybody. It's like, oh shoot, okay, we are mortal.
VerityYeah. They're like God told us this was gonna happen.
DakotaYeah. This is how easily it can happen.
VerityYeah. That's probably true. It's probably the first murder. It's a good point. Tough. See, these questions that I ask, it reminds me of when my husband comes home from an outing or a dinner, and I'll ask him all of these questions about the details of it. And he's like, I don't know. I didn't ask. And I have all of these follow-up questions. And he's like, I don't know. I feel like that's how I'm going through these stories. And I'm like, well, what about this? And tell me this. And what about this detail? And you're more on the bigger picture of it, right? And I'm more like, what was she wearing? You know, is where I'm in the details too much, probably.
DakotaYeah. And some of them are just kind of ancillary notes of things that don't really matter or affect anything. But there should be a lot more questions that people have when they do read this Bible that they should ask. And I think that's one really great thing about Christianity is the encouragement to know and to seek that comes directly from God Himself. And maybe that's what this podcast is really good for, just to get people to be like, you should ask questions. There's other systems of belief out there that encourage people not to ask questions. I mean, what is that? You know, you don't want people to ask questions. Why? Because there's very problematic things that you don't want people to think about or uncover or talk about. Well they don't know.
VerityOr they don't know. Like sometimes I give presentations through my job and don't feel super solid on the subject, so I'm like, I hope nobody asks questions.
DakotaYeah. True. Because you don't want them to uncover your lack of knowledge.
VerityYeah. Yeah.
DakotaYeah. But the Bible is like, yeah, you should ask. You should ask about this. And I think a lot of these things are meant to stir up questions to think about these things.
VerityAre there other questions that I should be asking about Cain and Abel?
DakotaUm I don't think any that we could get the answer from the text of. I mean, but you could ask, why does Cain have this type of heart and Abel not have that type of heart? And that's a question for God. I don't know what in their makeup or what in their experience either hardened Cain's heart or made Abel kind of more open and devout to Yahweh. We don't get that either. We just know that happened. And there's an instruction there for Cain that despite the fact that he is dealing with the type of heart that he has, um, he has to overcome it. Now Cain should ask a question at that point. He should ask how.
VerityYeah.
DakotaRight? What's he supposed to do? I think that's the question that he should ask.
VerityYeah. Wow. I feel like there's been like a lot of tests purposely put in place up to this point, like already, the tree of knowledge of good and evil. It's like a test.
DakotaWell, yeah.
VerityAnd then are you gonna do well with this? I rejected your offering. It's like a test.
DakotaAnd as we read it now, in hindsight, we're supposed to see maybe that God's highlighting for us what we are. Because we are humans like Adam and Eve. We're placed in that position and we do the same thing. Yeah, probably. And we're placed in Cain's position. Some of us are gonna do the same thing or worse.
VerityWell, yeah. I mean, I'm not gonna murder my brother, but if my offering gets rejected, I'm gonna be ticked off. I'm gonna be offended.
DakotaYeah. This is kind of the blueprint of what humans are naturally, I guess, is what we're seeing.
VerityWell, I'm naturally competitive, so I would probably be like, How is his better than mine?
DakotaYeah. Yeah.
VerityYeah.
DakotaAnd then your focus would be in the wrong place. Yeah. Maybe that's what he's trying to get him to see is you're looking at him, sending him out him. Yeah. Talking to you. It's kind of like when we talk to our kids, you know, I've got one kid in particular who shall not be named. You know who I'm talking about. And he'll always be like, Well, he well, he did, you know, he he's got, you know, it's like, well, I'm talking to you about what you did. I think I've heard you say that. Nothing to do with anybody else but you.
VerityWell, the next one's a little more interesting, and I'm a little excited because I've read ahead.
Next Time: Noah's Ark
VerityNext week we're gonna be talking about Noah's Ark. And normally what you see as baby nursery decor is not the spin I'm gonna take on it. I'm focused more on the drunkenness and the cursed ham.
DakotaCursed ham is a person, not a meat.
VerityYeah, I didn't know that. I literally thought it was a cursed ham, and I was like, this is gonna be interesting.
DakotaAnd you thought I always thought ham was a little funny.
VerityI mean, I'm not a big pork eater, but I did. Anyway, we'll get into it, but it intrigued me.
DakotaI hope you're intrigued as well, dear listener.
VerityAll right. Okay. Well, thank you.
DakotaUntil next time, let's do it.
VerityBye.